Not to sound Mean, but you guys are beating a dead horse here.
If you read this forum and the other forums related to MA - MAN all of these questions have been answered in one fashion or another at one place or another. I do like the summary that VaNo posted as it brings most of the content into one post. Thanks, VaNo!
My interpretation is this:
If you Have paid for and Use MA. Then what you have is what you've paid for. For me, it's a game that works great and gives me no problems what so ever (with the exception of when my net connection cut out, but that was not the fault of the game, only my ISP disconnecting). In addition with so many players on MA I can play the same maps over and over and still have new events take place and new strategies that come to mind. It also has the continued support from the Devs which is what I would expect.
IF you want the abilities for a better multiplaying online experience, then MAN is more suited for you and therefore should come at a price.
As stated before both are compatible with one another as an added bonus.
For myself, I don't get alot of time for online play so the MA system is perfect for my needs. It allows me to play a few turns before I go to work and play a few more after I get home before I go to bed.
If I were a person that had more time that could be devoted to online playing for 4 to 8 hours on end, then MAN would be my game of choice and I would pay for that service and the added feature rich experience it has to offer that MA does not.
Of course If I'm wrong, please let me know
